Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white

Fish Bay Real Estate

Average Home Price: $1,792,000
View 14 Listings

Fish Bay Real Estate Price Ranges

$879,000 - $3,299,000
1 Bed
$1,025,000 - $1,025,000
1 Listing
2 Beds
$1,799,000 - $1,799,000
1 Listing
3 Beds
$879,000 - $879,000
1 Listing
4 Beds
$1,250,000 - $3,299,000
3 Listings
Single Family
$879,000 - $3,299,000
6 Listings
$179,000 - $3,900,000
8 Listings

What people like about Fish Bay Real Estate

  • paved roads
  • South Shore ocean views
  • close to town but secluded
Area Details

Fish Bay Real Estate Guide

Positioned along the South Shore of St. John, the Fish Bay neighborhood offers both beautiful views and a true sense of belonging to an established community. Residents and visitors alike commonly characterize the neighborhood atmosphere as family oriented, an apt designation given the many families that call this neighborhood home. Many of the properties here overlook stunning Fish Bay, Ditleff Point and distant St. Croix, which sits 40 miles to the south of St. John. Ditleff Point – an emerald green peninsula that juts out into the ocean – makes for a dramatic backdrop to any of the area’s homes or villas.

The area is just as short 15 to 20 minute drive to the main town of Cruz Bay on a winding, paved road that reveals captivating views around almost every bend. Cruz Bay features an eclectic array of restaurants, bars, boutiques, galleries and dive shops. Like many of St. John’s neighborhoods on the South Shore, Fish Bay is conveniently located and accessible yet it’s still the right amount of secluded to feel like a Caribbean getaway. A blend of rental villas and long-time residents makes this area an ideal place to own a vacation home or live full-time. Because of its central location, Fish Bay is a sought after vacation rental location, which is good news for those who only plan on living on the island part-time.

The bay itself shelters a few sailboats that enhance the area’s gorgeous sunsets with their idyllic silhouettes. While the rocky bay isn’t the most suitable for casual swims, it is a great place to start a kayaking or paddle boarding adventure and white sandy beaches can be found in neighboring bays. Bordering the Virgin Islands National Park provides access to the many great hiking trails that traverse the island’s coastlines and ridgelines, with paths often leading to secluded, sandy white beaches.

Fish Bay Real Estate

Market Stats


Fish Bay Real Estate

Local Info

Cruz Bay shopping, dining and stores
Close to Marketplace (grocery store, video store, book/coffee shop, pharmacy, and more)
Close to Westin Resort

Casanita on St. John

View to Friis Bay The translation for Casanita in Spanish is "nice house." Nice house and so much more is what you will find with this 3 bed 3 bath home...

Tranquility in Dreeket’s Bay

Have you been to the East End of St. John? What about the Dreeket's Bay neighborhood? It is a very peaceful place on the island with unbelievable views....

You can OWN Christmas to New Years Eve at the Westin St. John… available this year 2022!

Check out the DRAMATIC PRICE REDUCTION on weeks 51 and 52, fractional ownership for TWO units at the Westin St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands. The perfect...

St. John Land for Sale At Every Price Range

St. John Land for Sale As housing inventory on St. John slims down, many prospective buyers are leaning into the idea of building. After all, building a custom...

St. John Leatherback Turtle Nest Hatches!

First Leatherback turtle nest since 2016 St. John's Sea Turtle nesting season began early this year with a Leatherback turtle nest. There was quite the excitement...

Fish Bay Real Estate

Featured Listings

122 Fish Bay 1
38 Photos
5 Beds 4.5 Baths 5,380 Sqft
122 Fish Bay
Reef Bay, St. John
145 & 147 Fish Bay 1
24 Photos
82 Fish Bay 1
21 Photos
5 Beds 6.5 Baths 4,317 Sqft
82 Fish Bay
Reef Bay, St. John

By joining you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy