Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white

Peter Bay

Average Home Price: $7,250,000
View 6 Listings

Peter Bay Price Ranges

$5,500,000 - $8,999,500
4 Beds
$5,500,000 - $8,999,500
2 Listings
Single Family
$5,500,000 - $8,999,500
2 Listings
$850,000 - $2,195,000
4 Listings

What people like about Peter Bay

  • beach access
  • 10-15 minute drive to Cruz Bay
  • private, gated community
  • all paved roads
  • ocean views
Area Details

Peter Bay Real Estate Guide

A prestigious and gorgeously designed community, Peter Bay stands outs amongst even the most renowned neighborhoods in the Virgin Islands. Finely built, Spanish-tiled roofs mark this cliff side, gated community that’s situated on the island’s exclusive North Shore. Fine, artistic touches and rich finishing work characterize the upscale community right down to the printed stamped concrete roadways and use of native stones. Those who live in Peter Bay are part of an uncommon, exceptional neighborhood that all can agree was designed with flawless taste. Many of the villas feature swimming pools, hot tubs and special outdoor areas, making them perfect for family vacations.

Nestled above a lavish white sand beach, the neighborhood offers privacy, luxury and comfort within a finely crafted community. The stunning villas are surrounded by a clear turquoise bay that’s encompassed by the Virgin Islands National Park, which has preserved nearly two-thirds of the land on St. John. With a limited number of developments on the North Shore as a result of the park, peacefulness and security characterize this tranquil neighborhood. Unobstructed views allow residents to gaze down on postcard worthy Cinnamon Bay, one of St. John’s most famous and a regular on the best beaches lists of many well-known international publications. This impressive neighborhood sets the bar high for upscale island living, attracting homeowners from around the world.

The community is just a short, 15-minute ride to Cruz Bay, so living in Peter Bay doesn’t limit access to all the amenities the island’s main hub has to offer like restaurants, bars, boutiques, galleries and dive shops. Bustling with activity, Cruz bay is full of restaurants and boutiques that are considered among the best in the Virgin Islands. Lush tropical landscaping and gorgeous views along with chicly paved roads and underground utilities contribute to the neighborhood’s sought after status.

Peter Bay

Market Stats


Peter Bay

Local Info

St. John’s best beaches
10-15 minutes from Cruz Bay
private beach

Casanita on St. John

View to Friis Bay The translation for Casanita in Spanish is "nice house." Nice house and so much more is what you will find with this 3 bed 3 bath home...

Tranquility in Dreeket’s Bay

Have you been to the East End of St. John? What about the Dreeket's Bay neighborhood? It is a very peaceful place on the island with unbelievable views....

You can OWN Christmas to New Years Eve at the Westin St. John… available this year 2022!

Check out the DRAMATIC PRICE REDUCTION on weeks 51 and 52, fractional ownership for TWO units at the Westin St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands. The perfect...

St. John Land for Sale At Every Price Range

St. John Land for Sale As housing inventory on St. John slims down, many prospective buyers are leaning into the idea of building. After all, building a custom...

St. John Leatherback Turtle Nest Hatches!

First Leatherback turtle nest since 2016 St. John's Sea Turtle nesting season began early this year with a Leatherback turtle nest. There was quite the excitement...

House Hunting – Easter Update

Hunting for a house Whether you were hunting for eggs or a house, St. John was a busy busy place this past week. The island was full with visitors and residents...

Peter Bay

Featured Listings

By joining you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy