12 Fish Bay, St. John, USVI 00830, MLS# 26-193

1 of 62 Photos Map

$2,150,000

7 Beds

6.5 Baths

4,435 Sqft

                Highlights of 12 Fish Bay
            

                
                                                Approx Ext Acres
                            0.5
                                                    Area
                            St John
                                                    Estate
                            Fish Bay
                                                    Landscaping
                            Professional
                                                    Quarter
                            Cruz Bay
                                                    Subdivision
                            Fish Bay
                                                    Total Bathrooms
                            6.5
                                                    Total SqFt
                            4,435
                                        
            

                
                                                Approx Int Sqft
                            2,960
                                                    Baths - Half
                            1
                                                    Island
                            St John
                                                    MLS #
                            26-193
                                                    Status
                            Active
                                                    Total Approx. SqFt
                            4,435
                                                    Total Bedrooms
                            7
                                                    Year Built
                            1991
                                        
            

Property Description
Crystal Shores Estate is set within a lush tropical setting in highly sought-after Fish Bay. Offering an exceptional combination of scale and versatility, this expansive 7 bedroom estate features a spacious main house and guest house, offering lots of flexibility. Multiple covered porches and expansive decks create an effortless connection to the outdoors, while the oversized pool and lounge area provide an impressive setting for entertaining and relaxation. The 3 bedroom guest house with separate driveway adds additional appeal and options. Currently operating as a successful short-term rental, the property offers the flexibility to live in the main home while renting additional units long or short term or vice versa! A rare opportunity with exceptional income potential.
Features
- AC/Fans: Yes
- Cistern Capacity +/- (gal.): 43, 000
- Cistern: Masonry
- Roof: Membrane
Additional Info
- Builder Name: Lubebke/Boyd
- Construction: Frame, Masonry
- Easements: of public record
- Grade: Gentle
- Restrictions: CCRs
- Sewer: Septic
- Zoning: R-2Residential
- Condition: Very Good
- Deck SqFt: 1,475
- Foundation: Masonry
- Insurance: Available
- Road Assessment Year: 2026.00
- Waterfront: N
Amenities
- Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Freezer, Refrigerator, Stove, Washer
- Pool: Yes
- Furnished: Yes
- View: Caribbean, Down Island, Harbor, South Shore, St. Croix
Fees and Taxes
- HOA Fee: $500
- Tax Year: 2026
- HOA Frequency: Annually
- Taxes: 7351.50

340.776.6666 Email Us

Name*
First Last
Phone
Email*
Message
I found this listing at 12 Fish Bay, St. John, USVI, 00830 and would like more information. Thank you.
Email
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

About this area
Fish Bay Real Estate

Fish Bay Real Estate Guide Positioned along the South Shore of St. John, the Fish Bay neighborhood offers both beautiful views and a true sense of belonging to an established community. Residents and visitors alike commonly characterize the neighborhood atmosphere as family oriented, an apt designation given the many families that call this neighborhood...

Price Range: $999,000 - $4,500,000

About This Area

View 13 listings